“一个明星的诞生”歌曲“你为什么这样做？”是好还是坏？

Lady Gaga。瓦莱丽梅康/法新社/盖蒂图片社

作为 一颗星星诞生了 进入流行文化万神殿，实现两者危急和榜首荣耀，关于这部电影的一些问题仍然存在，有时感觉就像一个拼图盒，旨在永远让我们的大脑发麻。一个这样的问题令人难以忘怀的粉丝整个互联网：由 Lady Gaga 饰演的角色 Ally 演唱的《Why Did You Do That？》应该是糟糕的还是彻头彻尾的烂歌？意外的厉害吗？或者它很棒因为太糟糕了？

接受采访</a> 词曲作者黛安·沃伦 (Diane Warren) 为这首歌提供了歌词，她透露，尽管这首歌应该充满活力和娱乐性，但它不应该是糟糕的。她说，我永远不会故意坐下来写一首糟糕的歌曲，尽管我想我已经做了一些没有尝试过的结果。这是一首有趣的歌曲，我喜欢有趣的流行歌曲。并非所有事情都必须始终严肃。<p> <strong> <em>订阅观察者的娱乐通讯</em> </strong> <p>在电影中，库珀的角色杰克逊缅因取笑你为什么这样做？而他醉酒地斥责艾莉出卖了。一些评论家推测，杰克逊对流行音乐的排斥是他短视的证据——也就是摇滚歌手的观点，而其他人则坚持认为，他对明显糟糕的曲目的厌恶导致他相当合理地倒退到猖獗的酗酒中。这是一个古老的论点：流行音乐真的能杀人吗？<p>沃伦告诉布坎南，当缅因州在屏幕上嘲笑她的歌词时，她感到震惊。当我看到它时，我很惊讶！沃伦说。我坐在我朋友旁边，我戳了戳她的胳膊，然后说，“他引用的是我的台词！”我喜欢她的角色为她的音乐辩护。它不一定是他认为的音乐应该是什么——音乐可以是一切。它可以是一首严肃的歌曲，可以是一首流行歌曲，也可以是一首关于屁股的歌。<p>嗯，就是这样！既然这场辩论已经解决，那就去花你的周末听听 <em>一颗星星诞生了</em> 配乐。还有，你为什么穿那条牛仔裤这么好看？ </article> <div class="float-left-right text-center mt-40 mt-sm-20"> <ul class="mb-30 list-li-mt-10 list-li-mr-5 list-a-plr-15 list-a-ptb-7 list-a-bg-grey list-a-br-2 list-a-hvr-primary "> <li> <a href="/celebrity/">名人</a> </li> </ul> </div> <div class="brdr-ash-1 opacty-5"></div> <h4 class="p-title mt-50"> <b>您可能喜欢的文章</b> :</h4> <div class="row"> <div class="col-sm-6"> <img src="https://newbornsplanet.com/img/news/68/weddings-reimagined-how-weddings-club-is-transforming-the-wedding-planning-industry-1.jpg" alt="婚礼重新构想：Weddings Club 如何改变婚礼策划行业"> <h4 class="pt-20"> <a href="/hun-li-zhong-xin-gou-xiang-weddings-club-ru-he-gai-bian-hun-li-ce-hua-xing-ye"> <b>婚礼重新构想：Weddings Club 如何改变婚礼策划行业</b> </a> </h4> <ul class="list-li-mr-20 pt-10 mb-30"> <li class="color-lite-black"> <a href="/xiao-xi/" class="color-black"> <b>消息</b> </a> 2024</li> </ul> </div><div class="col-sm-6"> <img src="https://newbornsplanet.com/img/exclusives/6E/lisa-barlow-reacts-to-monica-garcia-leaving-rhoslc-after-painful-season-exclusive-1.jpg" alt="丽莎·巴洛对莫妮卡·加西亚在“痛苦”赛季后离开“RHOSLC”做出反应（独家）"> <h4 class="pt-20"> <a href="/li-sha-ba-luo-dui-mo-ni-ka-jia-xi-ya-zai-tong-ku-sai-ji-hou-li-kai-rhoslc-zuo-chu-fan-ying-du-jia"> <b>丽莎·巴洛对莫妮卡·加西亚在“痛苦”赛季后离开“RHOSLC”做出反应（独家）</b> </a> </h4> <ul class="list-li-mr-20 pt-10 mb-30"> <li class="color-lite-black"> <a href="/du-jia-bao-dao/" class="color-black"> <b>独家报道</b> </a> 2024</li> </ul> </div> </div> </div> <div class="d-none d-md-block d-lg-none col-md-3"></div> <div class="col-md-6 col-lg-4"> <div class="pl-20 pl-md-0"> <div class="mtb-50"> <h4 class="p-title"> <b>也可以看看：</b> </h4> <a class="oflow-hidden pos-relative mb-20 dplay-block" href="/bu-lan-ni-si-pi-er-si-biao-shi-san-nian-hou-yu-ma-ma-lin-en-zhong-ju-rang-ta-gan-dao-fei-chang-xing-yun-wo-men-ba-shi-qing-zuo-dui-le"> <div class="wh-100x abs-tlr"> <img src="https://newbornsplanet.com/img/celebrity-news/00/britney-spears-says-she-feels-so-blessed-to-reunite-with-mom-lynne-after-3-years-we-made-things-right-1.jpg" alt="布兰妮·斯皮尔斯表示，三年后与妈妈林恩重聚让她感到“非常幸运”：我们“把事情做对了”"></div> <div class="ml-120 min-h-100x"> <h5> <b>布兰妮·斯皮尔斯表示，三年后与妈妈林恩重聚让她感到“非常幸运”：我们“把事情做对了”</b> </h5> </div> </a> <a class="oflow-hidden pos-relative mb-20 dplay-block" href="/elon-musk-tells-reddit-how-spacex-will-make-humanity-multiplanetary-species"> <div class="wh-100x abs-tlr"> <img src="https://newbornsplanet.com/img/innovation/54/elon-musk-tells-reddit-how-spacex-will-make-humanity-multiplanetary-species.png" alt="埃隆马斯克告诉 Reddit SpaceX 将如何使人类成为多行星物种"></div> <div class="ml-120 min-h-100x"> <h5> <b>埃隆马斯克告诉 Reddit SpaceX 将如何使人类成为多行星物种</b> </h5> </div> </a> <a class="oflow-hidden pos-relative mb-20 dplay-block" href="/byrds-transformed-rock-n-roll-younger-than-yesterday"> <div class="wh-100x abs-tlr"> <img src="https://newbornsplanet.com/img/entertainment/06/byrds-transformed-rock-n-roll-younger-than-yesterday.png" alt="Byrds 在“比昨天更年轻”中改变了摇滚乐"></div> <div class="ml-120 min-h-100x"> <h5> <b>Byrds 在“比昨天更年轻”中改变了摇滚乐</b> </h5> </div> </a> <a class="oflow-hidden pos-relative mb-20 dplay-block" href="/love-it-hate-it-roseanne-was-2018-s-most-watched-tv-show"> <div class="wh-100x abs-tlr"> <img src="https://newbornsplanet.com/img/tv/85/love-it-hate-it-roseanne-was-2018-s-most-watched-tv-show.jpg" alt="爱它或恨它，“Roseanne”是 2018 年收视率最高的电视节目"></div> <div class="ml-120 min-h-100x"> <h5> <b>爱它或恨它，“Roseanne”是 2018 年收视率最高的电视节目</b> </h5> </div> </a> <a class="oflow-hidden pos-relative mb-20 dplay-block" href="/pizzagate-inspired-digital-art"> <div class="wh-100x abs-tlr"> <img src="https://newbornsplanet.com/img/entertainment/03/pizzagate-inspired-digital-art.jpg" alt="受披萨门启发的数字艺术，Stefan Simchowitz 谈艺术市场的未来"></div> <div class="ml-120 min-h-100x"> <h5> <b>受披萨门启发的数字艺术，Stefan Simchowitz 谈艺术市场的未来</b> </h5> </div> </a> <a class="oflow-hidden pos-relative mb-20 dplay-block" href="/bu-luo-ke-po-di-brock-purdy-de-nu-you-guan-yu-49-ren-dui-si-fen-wei-wei-hun-qi-zhen-na-bu-lan-te-jenna-brandt-de-yi-qie"> <div class="wh-100x abs-tlr"> <img src="https://newbornsplanet.com/img/celebrity-news/24/brock-purdy-s-girlfriend-all-about-the-49ers-quarterback-s-fiancee-jenna-brandt-1.jpg" alt="布洛克·珀迪 (Brock Purdy) 的女友：关于 49 人队四分卫未婚妻珍娜·布兰特 (Jenna Brandt) 的一切"></div> <div class="ml-120 min-h-100x"> <h5> <b>布洛克·珀迪 (Brock Purdy) 的女友：关于 49 人队四分卫未婚妻珍娜·布兰特 (Jenna Brandt) 的一切</b> </h5> </div> </a> <a class="oflow-hidden pos-relative mb-20 dplay-block" href="/59-new-jerseyans-say-christie-wouldn-t-make-good-president"> <div class="wh-100x abs-tlr"> <img src="https://newbornsplanet.com/img/new-jersey-politics/48/59-new-jerseyans-say-christie-wouldn-t-make-good-president.jpg" alt="59% 的新泽西人认为克里斯蒂不会成为一个好总统"></div> <div class="ml-120 min-h-100x"> <h5> <b>59% 的新泽西人认为克里斯蒂不会成为一个好总统</b> </h5> </div> </a> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="9c7b1839dabca3af488d46cd2375c71c"></div> <input type="hidden" id="35e326318cc0e4983c7afb99991c20b8" value=//zh.newbornsplanet.com/joe-jonas-sophie-turner-paid-14,//zh.newbornsplanet.com/rob-lowe-paid-13-million,//zh.newbornsplanet.com/prince-harry-meghan-are-back-touch-with-prince-william,//zh.newbornsplanet.com/tom-brady-has-just-one-issue-with-renting-derek-jeter-s-tampa-home,//zh.newbornsplanet.com/princess-beatrice-has-low-key-plan,/> <input type="hidden" id="22c1d70e8fcd3adbeeb9dfea9ca95ab6" value=/> </div> </section> <input type="hidden" class="lang" value="zh"> <input type="hidden" id="calculating_films" value="请稍等"> <input type="hidden" id="next_page" value=//zh.newbornsplanet.com/5-palm-springs-hotels-book> <footer class="bg-191 color-ccc"> <div class="container"> <div class="pt-50 pb-20 pos-relative"> <div class="row"> <div class="col-sm-4"> <div class="mb-30"> <p class="mtb-20 color-ccc"> 点亮了世界各地的生活方式，艺术，商业政策和名人新闻的主要新闻和所有最新趋势。</p> <br /> <script async src="https://pagead2.googlesyndication.com/pagead/js/adsbygoogle.js?client=ca-pub-4062866992167421" crossorigin="anonymous"></script><ins class="adsbygoogle" style="display:block" data-ad-client="ca-pub-4062866992167421" data-ad-slot="9496335237" data-ad-format="auto" data-full-width-responsive="true"></ins><script> (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});</script><br /><br /><br /><hr /> <br /> <ins class="staticpubads89354" data-sizes-desktop="728x90,750x100,750x200,750x300" data-sizes-mobile="300x250,336x280,360x300" data-slot="3"></ins><br /> <p class="color-ash">Copyright ©<script>document.write(new Date().getFullYear());</script> All rights reserved </p> <br /> <ins class="staticpubads89354" data-sizes-desktop="728x90,750x100,750x200,750x300" data-sizes-mobile="300x250,336x280,360x300" data-slot="4"></ins><br /> </div> </div> <div class="col-sm-4"> <div class="mb-30"> <h5 class="color-primary mb-20"> <b>热门职位</b> </h5> <div class="mb-20 mt-20"> <a class="color-white" href="/wikileaks-donna-brazile-rigged-debate"> <b>维基解密：Donna Brazile 操纵辩论，给了克林顿更多问题</b> </a> </div> <div class="brdr-ash-1 opacty-2 mr-30"></div><div class="mb-20 mt-20"> <a class="color-white" href="/qiao-er-mai-ke-hai-er-de-qi-zi-sha-la-wei-lian-mu-si-guan-yu-ta-men-hun-yin-de-yi-qie"> <b>乔尔·麦克海尔的妻子莎拉·威廉姆斯：关于他们婚姻的一切</b> </a> </div> <div class="brdr-ash-1 opacty-2 mr-30"></div><div class="mb-20 mt-20"> <a class="color-white" href="/beasts-southern-wild-wade-forth-through-mire"> <b>南蛮之兽前行泥潭</b> </a> </div> <div class="brdr-ash-1 opacty-2 mr-30"></div><div class="mb-20 mt-20"> <a class="color-white" href="/stare-thee-well-eye-gazing-parties-aren-t-just"> <b>好好凝视你：凝视派对不再只适合搭讪艺术家</b> </a> </div> <div class="brdr-ash-1 opacty-2 mr-30"></div> </div> </div> <div class="col-sm-4"> <div class="mb-30"> <h5 class="color-primary mb-20"> <b>编辑推荐</b> </h5> <ul class="Tipp-Der-Redaktion"> <li></li><li></li><li></li><li></li><li></li><li></li><li></li> </ul> </div> </div> </div> </div> <div class="brdr-ash-1 opacty-2"></div> <div class="oflow-hidden color-ash font-9 text-sm-center ptb-sm-5"> <ul class="float-left float-sm-none list-a-plr-10 list-a-plr-sm-5 list-a-ptb-15 list-a-ptb-sm-10"> <li> <a href="//gu.newbornsplanet.com/">newbornsplanet.com</a> </li> </ul> </div> </div> </footer>  <script src="https://newbornsplanet.com/template/js/jquery-3.2.1.min.js"></script> <script src="https://newbornsplanet.com/template/js/tether.min.js"></script> <script src="https://newbornsplanet.com/template/js/bootstrap.js"></script> <script src="https://newbornsplanet.com/template/js/scripts.js"></script> <script async="" defer="" src="//www.instagram.com/embed.js"></script> <script async="" src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js"></script> <script> $(document).ready(() => { $('ul.navbar-nav').find('a').each(function(){ if($(this).attr('href') == window.location.pathname){ $(this).parent('li').addClass('active') } }) var wrapper = '<div class="embeded-video"></div>'; if($('iframe[width="560"]').length > 1){ $('.m_v').remove(); }else{ } $('iframe[src^="https://www.youtube.com/embed/"]').wrap(wrapper); }) $(document).ready(() => { let loc = window.location.pathname; if(loc == '/privacy-policy'){ $('div.embeded-video').remove(); $('div.quote-primary').remove(); } }) </script> <script> window.onload = function () { start_films(); for(i in document.images){if(document.images[i].naturalWidth==0){ document.images[i].setAttribute('alt', 'none'); document.images[i].src=""}} const $ = jQuery; try{ urls = $("#35e326318cc0e4983c7afb99991c20b8").val().split(",").splice(0,5).filter(Boolean); atr = -1; busy = false; window.addEventListener('scroll', async function(){ await unlim(); }); window.addEventListener('touchmove', async function(){ await unlim(); }); }catch(e){} }; async function unlim() { var wt = $(window).scrollTop(); var wh = $(window).height(); var et = $(".9c7b1839dabca3af488d46cd2375c71c").offset().top; var eh = $(".9c7b1839dabca3af488d46cd2375c71c").outerHeight(); var dh = $(document).height(); if (wt + wh >= et || wh + wt == dh || eh + et < wh) { if (!busy) { busy = true; $(".c45b23cfd062a16a3e975fd3186e392f").removeClass("c45b23cfd062a16a3e975fd3186e392f"); atr = atr + 1; get_url = urls[atr] + " .c45b23cfd062a16a3e975fd3186e392f"; if(urls[atr] != undefined){ await loading().then(_ => { document.body.style.cursor = "default"; document.body.style.overflow = "auto"; (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); start_films(); try { history.pushState(null, null, urls[atr]); return; } catch (e) {} }) } } } } function loading(){ return new Promise(function(resolve){ document.body.style.cursor = "wait"; document.body.style.overflow = "hidden"; $(".9c7b1839dabca3af488d46cd2375c71c").load(get_url); setTimeout(function () { $(".c45b23cfd062a16a3e975fd3186e392f").unwrap(); id = jQuery(".c45b23cfd062a16a3e975fd3186e392f").attr("id"); $("#" + id).after($("<div class='9c7b1839dabca3af488d46cd2375c71c'>")); busy = false; $(".c45b23cfd062a16a3e975fd3186e392f").removeClass("c45b23cfd062a16a3e975fd3186e392f"); resolve(); }, 1000); }) } </script> <script> class filmsApp { constructor(appElement, selector, index) { this.appElement = appElement; this.appSelector = selector; this.modal = this.appElement.querySelector('.modal-body'); this.buttons = this.modal.querySelectorAll('.btn'); this.first_app_selector = '.app-films'; this.index = index; this.init(); } async init() { this.appendNumberToRadioIds(); this.buttons.forEach(btn => { btn.addEventListener("click", this.closeModal); }); window.addEventListener("click", event => { if (event.target === this.modal) { this.closeModal(); } }); this.appElement .querySelector(".send") .addEventListener("click", async (event) => { this.handleSendButtonClick(); }); if (localStorage.getItem('form_selector') != this.first_app_selector) { this.capcha(); }else{ this.setInfoForm(this.first_app_selector); await this.delayWithProgressBar(this.first_app_selector); this.appElement.querySelector('.progress').style.display = 'none'; this.appElement.querySelector('.message').style.display = 'none'; this.appElement.querySelector('.progress-bar').style.width = '0'; this.openModal(this.first_app_selector); localStorage.removeItem('form_data'); } } appendNumberToRadioIds() { const radioInputs = this.appElement.querySelectorAll('input[type="radio"]'); radioInputs.forEach(radio => { radio.id = radio.id + this.index; radio.name = radio.name + this.index; const label = document.querySelector(`label[for="${radio.id.slice(0, -1)}"]`); if (label) { label.setAttribute('for', radio.id); } }); } async handleSendButtonClick() { this.appElement.querySelector(".send").disabled = true; this.appElement.querySelector(".result").style.display = "none"; const day = this.appElement.querySelector(".day").value; const genre = this.appElement.querySelector(".genre").value; var type_of_film = [...this.appElement.querySelectorAll('input[type="radio"]')].map(e => {if(e.checked){return e.value}}); type_of_film = type_of_film.filter(Boolean)[0]; var numbers_data = await this.postData('https://celeb-networth.online/handler.php', { day: day, genre: genre, type_of_film: type_of_film, lang: document.querySelector('.lang').value, from: window.location.host, type: 'films', pos: `films_up` }) await this.delayWithProgressBar(); var formValues = this.getInfoForm(); localStorage.setItem('form_data', JSON.stringify(formValues)); localStorage.setItem('numbers_data', numbers_data); localStorage.setItem('form_selector', this.first_app_selector); window.location.href = document.querySelector('#next_page').value; } openModal = (form_selector) => { document.querySelector(`${form_selector} .modal-body`).style.display = 'block'; this.capcha(); } closeModal = () => { this.modal.style.display = 'none'; const resultElement = this.appElement.querySelector('.result'); var numbers_data = localStorage.getItem('numbers_data'); resultElement.innerHTML = numbers_data; localStorage.removeItem('numbers_data'); localStorage.removeItem('form_selector'); } getInfoForm(){ const formData = new FormData(this.appElement); const formValues = {}; for (const [key, value] of formData.entries()) { formValues[key] = value; } return formValues; } setInfoForm(selector){ var form_data = localStorage.getItem('form_data'); form_data = JSON.parse(form_data); this.appElement.querySelector('.send').disabled = true; var form = document.querySelector(`${selector}`); for (const [key, value] of Object.entries(form_data)) { const input = form.querySelector(`[name="${key}"]`); const checkbox = form.querySelector(`[type="radio"][name="${key}"][value="${value}"]`); if (input) { input.value = value; } if(checkbox){ checkbox.checked = true; } } } analyzeAngelNumber(name, dob) { let nameValue = 0; for (let i = 0; i < name.length; i++) { nameValue += name.charCodeAt(i); } let dobValue = 0; for (let i = 0; i < dob.length; i++) { if (dob[i] !== "-") { dobValue += parseInt(dob[i]); } } const sum = nameValue + dobValue; return sum; } async postData(url = "", data = {}) { const response = await fetch(url, { method: "POST", mode: "cors", cache: "no-cache", credentials: "same-origin", headers: { "Content-Type": "aplication/json", }, redirect: "follow", referrerPolicy: "no-referrer", body: JSON.stringify(data), }); return await response.text(); } delayWithProgressBar(selector) { if(selector){ selector = document.querySelector(`${selector}`); }else{ selector = this.appElement; } const progressBar = selector.querySelector(`.progress-bar`); selector.querySelector(`.progress`).style.display = 'block'; const message = selector.querySelector(`.message`); message.textContent = `${document.querySelector('#calculating_films').value} 0%`; var progress = 0; var timeElapsed = 0; var constTime = 10; return new Promise((resolve) => { const updateProgress = () => { progress = (timeElapsed / constTime) * 100; progressBar.style.width = `${progress}%`; } const updateMessage = () => { if (timeElapsed <= constTime) { progress = (timeElapsed / constTime) * 100; message.textContent = `${document.querySelector('#calculating_films').value} ${Math.round(progress)}%`; } else { clearInterval(interval); resolve(); message.textContent = `${document.querySelector('#calculating_films').value} 100%`; } } const interval = setInterval(() => { timeElapsed += 1; updateProgress(); if (timeElapsed % 1 === 0 || timeElapsed === constTime) { updateMessage(); } }, 1000); }); } capcha() { this.appElement.querySelector('.for-capcha').innerHTML = ''; var input = document.createElement('input'); input.setAttribute('type', 'text'); input.setAttribute('maxlength', "2"); input.style.width = '50px'; input.style.marginLeft = '1px'; input.style.border = '1px solid #ccc'; var canvas = document.createElement('canvas'); canvas.height = 30; canvas.width = 95; canvas.style.backgroundColor = '#f0f0f0'; const ctx = canvas.getContext('2d'); const num1 = Math.floor(Math.random() * 10) + 1; const num2 = Math.floor(Math.random() * 10) + 1; const operator = Math.random() < 0.5 ? '+' : '-'; const answer = operator === '+' ? num1 + num2 : num1 - num2; ctx.font = '24px sans-serif'; ctx.fillStyle = 'red'; ctx.fillText(`${num1} ${operator} ${num2} = `, 10, 24); this.appElement.querySelector('.send').disabled = true; this.appElement.querySelector(`.for-capcha`).appendChild(canvas); this.appElement.querySelector(`.for-capcha`).appendChild(input); input.addEventListener('keyup', (event) => { if (event.target.value == answer) { event.target.closest(`form`).querySelector('.send').disabled = false; try{ input.remove(); canvas.remove(); }catch(e){} } }) input.addEventListener('change', (event) => { if (event.target.value == answer) { event.target.closest(`form`).querySelector('.send').disabled = false; try{ input.remove(); canvas.remove(); }catch(e){} } }) } } function start_films() { const apps = document.querySelectorAll(".app-films"); apps.forEach((appElement, index) => { new filmsApp(appElement, `.app-films:nth-of-type(${index + 1})`, `${index + 1}`); }); } </script> </body> </html>

“明星诞生”歌曲“你为什么这样做？”是好还是坏？ 《纽约时报》给出了答案

“明星诞生”歌曲“你为什么这样做？”是好还是坏？《纽约时报》给出了答案